Councilman Justin Brannan (D-Brooklyn) has been removed from the New York City Council’s Italian Caucus for his refusal to fully support Columbus Day. Brannan’s willingness to consider renaming the holiday as Italian-American Heritage Day has sparked tension within the caucus, which is largely made up of conservative members.
Brannan’s comments, made in 2023 and reiterated this year, led to his expulsion from the caucus. David Carr (R-Staten Island), who chairs the group, explained that Brannan’s position directly conflicted with the caucus’ commitment to retaining Columbus Day as a federal holiday. “There’s no room for debate on this,” Carr stated.
Brannan, a proud Italian-American, rejected what he called a “MAGA litmus test,” arguing that the holiday should celebrate Italian contributions to the country rather than focusing on Columbus. He also voiced his support for a separate holiday for Indigenous peoples.
The caucus, which includes conservative members like Councilwoman Vickie Paladino (R-Queens), revised its bylaws to ensure that members must fully support Columbus Day. This led to Brannan’s exclusion from a City Council-sponsored Italian Heritage Celebration.
Councilman Robert Holden (D-Queens) supported Brannan’s removal, criticizing him for diluting Italian heritage in favor of “woke” ideals. Holden suggested that Brannan’s focus should be on preserving tradition rather than aligning with current political trends.
